Friday, March 09, 2012

Health & Education

This past Wednesday in church we covered the candidates on the issues of environment, energy, health care, entitlements, and education. Yes, we covered a lot of ground. Here are my personal ratings:

5 points: Newt Gingrich
I think he does the best job of articulating a stewardship mindset about the environment. He's not an environmentalist wacko OR indifferent about the environment (though I do think his positions change based on whether he's in an election or not). But he got most of his points on education. I like the funds being linked to the child and not the school district idea. I also think he's right about leaving education to the states with the federal government playing the role of swapping stories of success.

3 points: Ron Paul
The main area Paul got points from me here was on entitlements. He believes the entitlement system is heading toward bankruptcy. We need to teach people against the 'entitlement' mindset. This would be a painful but necessary process.

2 points: Mitt Romney
Nothing really of note here. Nothing made me excited or mad. Pretty 'moderate'... go figure

1 point: Rick Santorum
See above

-2 points: Barack Obama
Obviously he supports ObamaCare which I think is a move in the wrong direction. I don't profess to be an expert in such things, but given our deficits I don't think moving health care into the entitlement realm is a long term solution.


Anonymous said...

How do you feel about Romneycare? do you think it differs significantly from obamacare?

matthew said...

I doubt it is very different in policy, but it is substantially different in principle. A don't particularly favor a state-run health care system, but it is surely preferable to a national-run health care system. My view is that things like health care need to be as contextual as possible. So the bigger the organization in charge of it, the less patient oriented the system tends to become. This is mostly a gut opinion though.