Tuesday, November 28, 2006

Gilmore Girls 9

Gilmore Girls Survivor
On the day of the next 6 'new' episodes, you will find the names of 3 randomly selected characters from the show. Your job is to vote FOR (+1) your favorite AND AGAINST (-1) your least favorite (and explain why). The cast member with the worst result of the trio will be eliminated from the tournament.

Paris
Jess
Logan




Vote away. And check back later for my review of tonight's episode

11 comments:

matthew said...

FOR: Paris
AGAINST: Logan

I didn't like Paris at first, but now she's on of my favorite characters. I like her biting sarcasm and her unique personality.

I don't like Logan b/c he's pretty snobby at times and cheated on Rory. I'll give him some credit as he has shown some improvement, but mostly I don't like him b/c Rory seems to not be herself when she's with him.

Kirk said...

For: Jess
Against: Logan

As an avid watcher of the first 2 seasons I have to say Jess is just hott. That is right hott with 2 ts. Logan on the other hand isn't even memorable for me. I can honestly say I don't remember a single episode he was in. I didn't vote against Paris because she may be smarter than me. (and therefore could provide a challenge for me in scattegories) (but I doubt it)

Heather Durkee said...

For: Paris
Against: Jess



-Paris is hilarious! I always loved the craft table too!
-Jess didn't fight enough for Rory.

**This was hard since I am not that big of a fan of any of these three.

Elliott Innes said...

FOR: Jess
AGAINST: Logan

I'm voting for Jess basically because he is the misunderstood rebel. Everyone thinks he's bad news, but he was probably the best thing that ever happened to Rory. We have never seen anyone, including Dean, who has cared so much about her and been so aligned with her thoughts and interests. Dean just wanted her for her body.

As far as Logan. If Rory were to fall for him for good, she would be heading down the same road that Lorelei did with Chris, a life of bureaucratic, high society crap that will ultimately leave her feeling cheap and empty.

Dena said...

For: Paris
Against: Logan

Man, this was so tough. I definately think Logan is not good for Rory. It was tough between Paris and Jess. Paris annoyed me at first, but then her character grew and we could see the good in her. Jess understood some things about Rory that Dean never did. They had the whole intellectual thing in common, but in the end Paris wins by a nose.

matthew said...

current results

Paris +3
Jess +1
Logan -4

Jo said...

For: Paris
Against: Logan

Paris certainly could beat Kirk Perry at Scattergories, and I will vote for simply because of that.

I voted against Logan simply because I detest him and his pretentious aristo-snot-ic kind (in all Christian love of course).

Jess of course, is almost decent. At least he has developed an emotional intelligence, has done something constructive (wrote a book), and in the latter season, has challenged Rory to be who she really is. Jess could turn out to be a really really good guy. Especially for a someone who started out a selfish scrapper.

matthew said...

Paris +5
Jess +1
Logan -6

matthew said...

good feedback Jo! Here's my reaction to the various characters in this episode.

Lorelei- She's definitely still uncomfortable with the marriage. I think the only thing motivating her to make it work right now is b/c the town doesn't really like him. The town, in this sense, is like her parents. She wants to rebel against them.

Chris- He's super boring. Paying for the bridge was dumb. He's just so...plastic.

Richard & Emily- They were fairl funny tonight

Rory- I really really like her this season when she's not with Logan. Like, a lot.

Logan- Thankfully, he wasn't in this episode much, perhaps his days are numbered?

Marty- Finally stopped acting like a jerk. For a minute. Then stuck his foot in his mouth. But they definitely seem to be going somewhere with this storyline.

Paris- Near the top of her game tonight.

Jackson- One of my favorite characters on the show. He made me laugh tonight and, like me, I'm pretty sure he doesn't like Chris much.

Luke- Once again, he's coming off as a near hero right now. He's funny and his storyline is interesting.

Acting issues: I thought TJ and April had some below average acting in this episode.

matthew said...

fox news is now projecting that Logan will be the 1st character eliminated from GG Survivor. but feel free to keep voting for another handful of hours

Kirk said...

Uhhhh this is Logan. Kirk said I could use his computer. Why do you hate me so? Deep down I have Rory's best interests in mind. If I am allowed to vote I'd like to vote for me and a negative for Paris. Don't hate me, Rory is my lobster.